Reviews for Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Color on ULTA.com - Cosmetics, Fragrance, Salon and Beauty Gifts

Search Review Center

Narrow By

Rating

Best Uses

Everyday (42) Going Out (24) Work (23) Natural Effect (18) Smokey Effect (11) Smoky Look (2) Thicker Line (2) Thin Defined Line (1) When you are in a hurry (1)

Pros

Applies Smoothly (42) Long Lasting (38) Great color (35) Blends Easily (28) Crease Resistant (24) Silky Texture (22) Highly Pigmented (16) Glides On Smoothly (6) Easy To Apply (5) Doesn't Run (3) Bold Color (2) Easy Removal (2) GREAT SMOKEY LOOK (1) Works For A Casual Look (1) Works For A Date Look (1)

Cons

Creases (4) Doesn't Blend Well (4) Wears Off Easily (3) Smudges or Flakes (2) Clumps in dark patches (1) Difficult To Apply (1) Difficult To Remove (1) Expensive (1) Hard to take off (1) Not very pigmented (1) Not waterproof (1) Resistant to skin (1) There are none (1) Too Sparkly (1)

Describe yourself

Classic Style (26) Natural Style (19) Trendy Style (8)

Related Searches

Waterproof Eyeshadow Stila Eyeliner Waterproof Eyeliner Eyeshadow Crayon Waterproof Eyeliner Primer Stila Smudge Crayon Stila Eyeshadow Smudge Crayon Eye Crayon

Your Beauty Path:
Home
Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Color

Stila

Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Color

View Options

From: $22.00

Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Color by Stila is a waterproof, primer eyeshadow and eyeliner in one.

Reviews 1 - 15 of 54

view all Page: 1 2 3 4

By Cynthiac

from Chino Hills, CA

About Me Classic Style

5/13/2013

Love it!

5.0

PROS

Bold Color
Glides On Smoothly
Easy To Apply
Long-Lasting
Doesn't Run

CONS

Difficult to Remove
Expensive

BEST USES

Thin Defined Line
Thicker Line
Everyday
Going Out

Comments:

Love this eyeliner! It last all day and never smudges even when I rub my eyes. Its more expensive but worth it as I do not have to reapply at all.

By Gray Dame

from Hoffman Estates, IL

About Me Natural Style

3/22/2013

Would absolutely buy this product again.

5.0

PROS

Glides On Smoothly
Easy To Apply
Blends Easily

CONS

There are none

BEST USES

Smoky Look
Everyday
Thicker Line

Comments:

Love, love, love it. It's the best eye liner pencil I've ever used. It also has a built-in sharpener.

By Hj

from San Gabriel ca

About Me Natural Style

2/23/2013

Love it!

5.0

PROS

Glides On Smoothly
Easy To Apply
Long-Lasting

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday

Comments:

I love how long it lasts and doesn't run down my eyes.

By geebee

from Castle Rock, CO

About Me Natural Style

1/18/2013

Perfect alone or as a primer

5.0

PROS

Applies Smoothly
Great Color
Long Lasting
Crease Resistant
Silky Texture
Blends Easily

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday
Going Out
Natural Effect
Work

Comments:

I don't wear much makeup (this product, eyeliner and mascara) and I love this to addd just a bit of color. Or when I do wear makeup it works well as a primer to help the eye shadow last.

By Rnw212

from Frankenmuth, MI

About Me Classic Style

1/07/2013

Love it

5.0

PROS

Long Lasting
Applies Smoothly
Blends Easily

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday
Work

Comments:

Use it daily as an eye base color. Not sure if it has good staying power normally because I use an eye primer?

By Lisa

from Oceanside, CA

About Me Classic Style

12/30/2012

Umber

5.0

PROS

Crease Resistant
Highly Pigmented
Long Lasting
Great Color
Applies Smoothly

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday

Comments:

This color is perfect for my hazel eye. It's not a bright purple nor dull brown but a beautiful warm mix of the two with a hint of gold. When black is too harsh, this is it!

By JustJet

from Peoria, AZ

About Me Classic Style

12/26/2012

Love Stila!

5.0

PROS

Great Color
Highly Pigmented
Crease Resistant
Long Lasting
Applies Smoothly
Silky Texture
Blends Easily

CONS

BEST USES

Going Out
Everyday
Smokey Effect

Comments:

I love Stila eye liners and this one doesn't disappoint. Beautiful color, right amount of shine that goes on easily. I can do thick or thin lines. Just don't wait to long to blend - because once it sets...it's set.

By Margaret

from Charlotte, NC

About Me Classic Style

11/30/2012

Great eyeliner

5.0

PROS

Great Color
Applies Smoothly
Silky Texture

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday
Natural Effect

Comments:

I love this as an eyeliner - it is so easy to apply and looks great.

By shoppin robin

from buffalo, ny

About Me Natural Style

11/09/2012

loved the other ones i bought, so i had

5.0

PROS

Blends Easily
Silky Texture
Long Lasting
Applies Smoothly
Great Color

CONS

BEST USES

Natural Effect
Everyday

Comments:

applies smoothly and does not make my eyes "itchy"

By Viv

from Orlando, FL

About Me Classic Style

10/31/2012

best smudge crayon ever!

5.0

PROS

Applies Smoothly
Blends Easily
Crease Resistant
Great Color
Long Lasting

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday

Comments:

this crayon i use everyday, whether for Dress or Casual!

By Ginger

from Boston, ma

About Me Classic Style

10/21/2012

Nice waterproof shadow

5.0

PROS

Silky Texture
Applies Smoothly
Great Color
Blends Easily
Crease Resistant
Long Lasting

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday
Going Out

Comments:

I use this as a base - then put matte shadow on top for a nice effect.

By Marjorie

from Fort Lee,NJ

About Me Natural Style

10/16/2012

Excellent product.

5.0

PROS

Long Lasting
Crease Resistant
Applies Smoothly
Blends Easily
Silky Texture
Great Color
Highly Pigmented

CONS

BEST USES

Everyday
Going Out
Smokey Effect

Comments:

Use everyday. Easy to apply and looks great. I love that I don't have to use a sharpner like all the others at Ulta. That made the sale for me.

By bob

from tulsa, ok

About Me Trendy Style

10/13/2012

great product

5.0

PROS

CONS

BEST USES

Comments:

love it

By awill316

from Washington, D.C.

About Me Classic Style

9/28/2012

GREAT product

5.0

PROS

Applies Smoothly
Long Lasting
Highly Pigmented
Silky Texture
Great Color
Crease Resistant

CONS

Doesn't Blend Well

BEST USES

Natural Effect
Everyday
Work
Smokey Effect
Going Out

Comments:

I have very oily eyelids but this Stila Smudge Crayon worked wonderfully! I didn't even have to use a primer underneath and this eye color stayed on all day long. The colors are very pretty as well.

By amy

from florida

About Me Natural Style

9/27/2012

great color

5.0

PROS

Applies Smoothly
Great Color
Long Lasting
Blends Easily

CONS

BEST USES

Natural Effect
Going Out
Everyday

Comments:

i use this as an eyeliner- and love it!

view all Page: 1 2 3 4